While its no secret anymore it still has some of the best pies in NYC, and possibly the world. With a claim like that you know there will be a line. They don’t take reservations, and they don’t do carryout, so be prepared to wait. While you’re waiting you can grab a cocktail, beer, or even some homemade limoncello. Now for the main attraction. Without a doubt you need to get the Hellboy and Cherry Jones (red hot if you’re feeling spicy), and if that is not enough throw in Monte Cristo or King Harry Classic. Really you won’t go wrong with any pie.